Can DxO PhotoLab replace Lightroom? Yes! But it does depend on how you use Lightroom

DxO PhotoLab’s editing tools go further than Lightroom’s and its RAW processing is on another level. Its cataloguing tools, however, are much less sophisticated. Image credit: Rod Lawton

The appeal of DxO PhotoLab as an alternative to Adobe Lightroom is strong. It’s available as a one-off perpetual license with no subscription, it’s not pursuing the generative AI rabbit hole that Adobe seems to have fallen into and it offers perhaps the best RAW processing, denoising and lens corrections of any photo-editor on the market.

But DxO PhotoLab and Lightroom are very different programs, so that although they share many of the same tools and features, they cater for very different user types and image-editing needs. 

So let’s break this down into different areas to see how DxO PhotoLab compares to Lightroom and what you can expect when making the swap.

  1. Editing tools: PhotoLab is a little more technical. There are more adjustments spread across a number of different panels. The bottom line is that whatever adjustments Lightroom can do, PhotoLab can do it just as well and often rather better. You might just need to work at it a little more.
  2. Image quality: If you shoot RAW, then it’s a clear win for PhotoLab. DxO’s custom lens corrections go further than the profiles offered by Lightroom. In particular, they automatically counteract the edge softness you get with some lenses. DxO’s DeepPRIME denoising process is still better and sharper than Lightroom’s AI denoising. If outright maximum image quality is your thing, PhotoLab has it sewn up.
  3. Masking tools: Lightroom’s masking tools are relatively straightforward and its AI masking tools work very well for the most part. PhotoLab’s AI masking tools are just as good but, characteristically, a little more complicated for the uninitiated. But PhotoLab also has very clever Control Point and Control Line masking which Lightroom does not have, together with some very subtle mask refinement tools.
  4. Non-destructive editing: Both programs work completely non-destructively so that you can undo or modify your changes at any point in the future. Both programs offer virtual copies so that you can try out different treatments without creating duplicate files. (Actually, Lightroom Classic can, but Lightroom relies on ‘Versions’ which are less accessible and less useful.)
  5. Presets: If you like styling your images with one-click presets, Lightroom wins hands down. There are so many bundled with the program that you might never need more, but if you do there are countless commercial and free preset packs out there. PhotoLab does come with a few presets of its own and you can make your own, but it’s not really its forté.
  6. Cataloguing and browsing: With Lightroom you have to import your images into a catalog, but once that’s done you get much more sophisticated organizing, filtering and search tools. PhotoLab is essentially a folder browser with the ability to create virtual ‘Projects’ (i.e. Albums) as well. It’s much more basic, but you may find it enough for your needs and there’s no import process.
  7. Cloud storage: This is a clear win for Lightroom. Lightroom Classic can synchronise Collections with the cloud, while Lightroom (not Classic) uses cloud storage exclusively to make all your images available everywhere, on any device. It also opens up an online community of photographers sharing comments, edits and presets. PhotoLab has nothing like this. It’s an old-school desktop-based application using local storage.
  8. Cost of ownership: People complain about Adobe’s ongoing subscription charge and how much better a single perpetual license is, but they forget that even ‘perpetual’ software gets major paid updates, and in PhotoLab’s case these are every year. You can skip a version, but if you skip two then you fall off the upgrade path and have to start again with a full license fee. PhotoLab is sold with a ‘perpetual’ license, but while you can use that version for ever, it won’t stay useful for ever without periodic upgrades.

So what’s the answer? Can you really swap from Lightroom to DxO PhotoLab?

Yes, if your primary interest is achieving maximum image quality from RAW files using powerful and effective masking and editing tools, if simpler folder/project based organisation is all you need and you’re not bothered about presets or cloud storage.

No, if you need to sync photos between devices via the cloud, you need heavyweight asset management tools and you love messing with presets. Lightroom is better if you’re not bothered by (or don’t notice) that slight drop in quality and control and it’s more important to be able to work at speed with large numbers of images.

• If you use a Windows machine, do check PhotoLab’s hardware requirements to make sure you can run it. Of course, you can always download the trial version to find out.

I hope that helps!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.