|

Why don’t I talk about ACDSee?

ByRod Lawton

I review a lot of software on Life after Photoshop but I rarely talk about ACDSee. Why? On the face of it, ACDSee Photo Studio 2025 is a powerful all-in-one photo organizing, developing and editing tool that embraces the latest developments in AI and is available both as a subscription and subscription free. So what’s not to like?

ACDSee Photo Studio 2025 Ultimate screenshot

Well I have in fact reviewed ACDSee Photo Studio 2025 Ultimate for Amateur Photographer and you can follow the link to see what I think of it. I’ve tried to be as fair and open-minded as possible, but it’s not software I would really recommend to anyone, which is why I rarely mention it on this site.

So what’s the problem? It’s this: ACDSee is an old-fashioned approach to image organisation which is, in my opinion, long past its sell-by-date. On paper it might appear to do everything that Lightroom and Photoshop can between them, and there are aspects to it that might appeal to people who like a more traditional workflow and aren’t, let’s say it, professional photographers.

But I find it clunky and limited. The cataloguing might be import-free but it doesn’t approach the sophistication and efficient of Lightroom or Capture One. The RAW processing is reasonable, though not in the top echelon, but its lens correction profile matching leaves a lot to be desired. Its non-destructive Develop mode crosses over confusingly with its ‘destructive’ pixel-based Edit mode, and the Edit mode offers similar-looking layer and masking tools to Photoshop, but without Photoshop’s depth, finesse and control.

What ACDSee Photo Studio 2025 lacks in particular is a library of preset effects to inspire the user. It’s a distinctly technical photo editor which will get the job done but offers little to get you started on your creative journey.

I’m sure many ACDSee Photo Studio users will disagree. That’s fine. But my impression is that ACDSee (and perhaps its users – sorry) occupy a bubble, outside of which nothing else exists. I really do think you can only be impressed by this software if you’ve not used any of its modern rivals, such as Lightroom Classic, Capture One, ON1 Photo RAW (especially ON1 Photo RAW), DxO PhotoLab, the Nik Collection… the list goes on.

ACDSee Photo Studio 2025 is, to me, an aging relic kept going with yearly injections of new on-trend features. I feel the same way about Corel PaintShop Pro and Adobe Photoshop Elements. Photo editing software shouldn’t be this complicated, this clunky.

And before anyone complains that I’m a Mac users and biased against Windows – that’s not true. I use Windows laptops and I’ve reviewed a lot of Windows software. Over my career I’ve probably spent as much time with Windows as I have with macOS. There is an ACDSee Photo Studio for Mac version, by the way, which I have reviewed on this site.

I guess my principal complaint about ACDSee Photo Studio is that it seems happy to be nearly as good as mainstream, modern rivals but mainly cheaper. It’s a pitch based on value and deals, with precious little actual quality involved. That, to me, does not seem a basis for choosing software, and if anyone asked me what photo editing software I would recommend, I can’t think of a single reason for recommending this.

Similar Posts

  • Radiant Photo review

    ByRod Lawton

    Verdict: 4 stars Radiant Photo sounds like countless other ‘magic’ photo apps and plug-ins that use the power of AI to make your photos perfect. The difference is that it works. Not every image will be transformed equally, but the dullest, most difficult and downright impossible images are the ones that get the most benefit.

  • DxO ViewPoint 5 review

    ByRod Lawton

    Verdict: 3.5 stars DxO ViewPoint 5 is a specialised distortion and correction tool which has some clever features but is a bit of an awkward fit with most editing workflows, partly because it can’t open and correct RAW files and partly because most applications you might launch it from have distortion and perspective correction tools of their own.

  • DxO ViewPoint 4 review

    ByRod Lawton

    Verdict: 3.8 stars DxO ViewPoint 4 takes distortion and perspective correction to a new level, with Volume Deformation correction, a new ReShape local warping tool and more. But its core perspective correction tools will likely already exist in any host application you choose to launch it from. For ultimate perspective and distortion control, it’s hard to fault – as long as you do actually need what it does.

  • ACDSee Photo Studio for Mac 8 review

    ByLife after Photoshop

    Verdict: 2.5 stars ACDSee Photo Studio for Mac 8 is the MacOS version of ACDSee’s all-in-one Photo Studio application. From its features, it looks like a strong rival to Lightroom or ON1 Photo RAW, for example, but the reality is very different. It’s both basic and technical at the same time, it’s missing features many might take for granted, and it looks like a Windows program ported on to the Mac, even if it isn’t.

  • DxO PhotoLab 9 AI masking tools explained, with examples

    ByRod Lawton

    DxO PhotoLab already had a formidable set of local adjustment tools, including some that rivals don’t have. PhotoLab’s clever control point masks and control lines, which effectively combine linear masks with selective masking, are unique to DxO. But other makers had already introduced AI masking with automatic region, subject and object detection, so it was about time PhotoLab caught up – and that’s exactly what DxO has done with the launch of PhotoLab 9.